When Guderian Shouted At Hitler.....
There were very few generals in the German Army who had the guts to argue with Hitler. Zeitzler was one. Guderian was another. He yelled at Hitler.
Below is an extract from Cornelius Ryan's The Last Battle, about the failed relief attempt on Kustrin in March 1945:
There was a moment of silence. Then Guderian began to speak quietly. "I Have already explained to you..."
Hitler waving his arm, cut him off. "Explanations! Excuses! That's all you give me!" he shouted. "Well! Then you tell me who let us down at Kustrin - the troops or Busse?"
Guderian suddenly boiled. "Nonsense!" he spluttered. "This is nonsense!" He almost spat the words out. Furious, his face reddening, he launched into a tirade. "Busse is not to blame!" he bellowed. "I've told you that! He followed orders! Busse used all the ammunition that was available to him! All that he had! Guderian's anger was monumental. He struggled for words. "To say that the troops are to blame - look at the casualties!". he raged. "Look at the losses! The troops did their duty! Their self-sacrifice proves it!"
Hitler yelled back. "They failed!" he raged. "They failed."
Guderian, his face purpling, roared at the top of his voice: "I must ask you... I must ask you not to level any further accusations at Busse or his troops!"
Both men were beyond reasonable discussion, but they did not stop. Facing each other, Guderian and Hitler engaged in such a furious and terrifying exchange that officers and aides stood frozen in shock.
Hitler, lashing out at the General Staff, called them all "spineles," "fools" and "fatheads." He ranted that they had constantly "misled," "misinformed" and "tricked" him.
Guderian challenged the Fuhrer on his use of the words "misinformed" and "misled." Had General Gehlen in his intelligence estimate "misinformed" about the strength of the Russians? "No!" roared Guderian.
"Gehlen is a fool!" Hitler retorted.
What of the surrounded eighteen divisions still in the Baltic states, in Courland? "Who," barked Guderian, "has misled you about them? Exactly when," he demanded of the Fuhrer, "do you intend to evacuate the Courland army?"
Source: http://www.feldgrau.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=26&t=11745
Suggested Reading
Below is an extract from Cornelius Ryan's The Last Battle, about the failed relief attempt on Kustrin in March 1945:
There was a moment of silence. Then Guderian began to speak quietly. "I Have already explained to you..."
Hitler waving his arm, cut him off. "Explanations! Excuses! That's all you give me!" he shouted. "Well! Then you tell me who let us down at Kustrin - the troops or Busse?"
Guderian suddenly boiled. "Nonsense!" he spluttered. "This is nonsense!" He almost spat the words out. Furious, his face reddening, he launched into a tirade. "Busse is not to blame!" he bellowed. "I've told you that! He followed orders! Busse used all the ammunition that was available to him! All that he had! Guderian's anger was monumental. He struggled for words. "To say that the troops are to blame - look at the casualties!". he raged. "Look at the losses! The troops did their duty! Their self-sacrifice proves it!"
Hitler yelled back. "They failed!" he raged. "They failed."
Guderian, his face purpling, roared at the top of his voice: "I must ask you... I must ask you not to level any further accusations at Busse or his troops!"
Both men were beyond reasonable discussion, but they did not stop. Facing each other, Guderian and Hitler engaged in such a furious and terrifying exchange that officers and aides stood frozen in shock.
Hitler, lashing out at the General Staff, called them all "spineles," "fools" and "fatheads." He ranted that they had constantly "misled," "misinformed" and "tricked" him.
Guderian challenged the Fuhrer on his use of the words "misinformed" and "misled." Had General Gehlen in his intelligence estimate "misinformed" about the strength of the Russians? "No!" roared Guderian.
"Gehlen is a fool!" Hitler retorted.
What of the surrounded eighteen divisions still in the Baltic states, in Courland? "Who," barked Guderian, "has misled you about them? Exactly when," he demanded of the Fuhrer, "do you intend to evacuate the Courland army?"
Source: http://www.feldgrau.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=26&t=11745
Suggested Reading
Labels:
Dramatic Moments,
Guderian Hitler arguments,
Heinz Guderian,
Hitler,
Kustrin,
WW2
Advertisement
Popular Articles On This Site
-
Churchill said to the Germans in January, 1945, "We Allies are no monsters. This, at least, I can say, on behalf of the United Nations...
-
For decades after the Second World War ended German soldiers from the Heer, Luftwaffe, and the Kriegsmarine have maintained that during the...
-
“We too are an army of rapists,” anonymous soldier, letter to the editor, Time Magazine, November 12, 1945. In Hollywood movies we ...
-
"Soldiers are rapists" KURT TUCHOLSKY We have discussed extensively on the rape committed by Russian, American and...
-
A North Vietnamese militia fighter girl smiles triumphantly as she passes by a downed American B 52 bomber. Last days: South Vietnam...
-
Here are images from the Battle of Stalingrad in the early stages when the Germans were sure of eventual victory and the Russians were fig...
-
We generally associate rape during WW2 with the mass rape of German women by the Red Army soldiers. It was said that the American soldiers ...
-
Red Army attacks Koenigberg. 1945 'The city fell in ruins and burned. The German positions were smashed, the trenches ploughed up, emb...
-
"War is not black and white. There are no good guys and bad guys" The second country after Poland where the "Germans que...
-
Rape is a part of war. It should not be. But reality is, nobody fight wars following the Queensberry rules. The Geneva Conventions to be mo...